CMS ENERGY CORPORATION 06/05/2016 AGM
1aElect Jon E. BarfieldFor
1bElect Deborah H. ButlerFor
1cElect Kurt L. DarrowFor
1dElect Stephen E. EwingFor
1eElect Richard M. GabrysFor
1fElect William D. HarveyFor
1gElect Philip R. Lochner Jr.For
1hElect Patricia K. PoppeFor
1iElect John G. RussellOppose
1jElect Myrna M. SotoFor
1kElect John G. SznewajsFor
1lElect Laura H. WrightFor
2Advisory vote on executive compensationOppose
3Appoint the auditorsAbstain