

| CMS ENERGY CORPORATION | 06/05/2016 AGM | |
|---|---|---|
| 1a | Elect Jon E. Barfield | For |
| 1b | Elect Deborah H. Butler | For |
| 1c | Elect Kurt L. Darrow | For |
| 1d | Elect Stephen E. Ewing | For |
| 1e | Elect Richard M. Gabrys | For |
| 1f | Elect William D. Harvey | For |
| 1g | Elect Philip R. Lochner Jr. | For |
| 1h | Elect Patricia K. Poppe | For |
| 1i | Elect John G. Russell | Oppose |
| 1j | Elect Myrna M. Soto | For |
| 1k | Elect John G. Sznewajs | For |
| 1l | Elect Laura H. Wright | For |
| 2 | Advisory vote on executive compensation | Oppose |
| 3 | Appoint the auditors | Abstain |