VALERO ENERGY CORPORATION 03/05/2018 AGM
1AElect Director H. Paulett EberhartAbstain
1BElect Director Joseph W. GorderOppose
1CElect Director Kimberly S. GreeneFor
1DElect Director Deborah P. MajorasFor
1EElect Director Donald L. NicklesFor
1FElect Director Philip J. PfeifferFor
1GElect Director Robert A. ProfusekFor
1HElect Director Stephen M. WatersFor
1LElect Director Randall J. WeisenburgerFor
1JElect Director Rayford Wilkins, Jr.For
2Ratify KPMG LLP as AuditorsOppose
3Advisory Vote on Executive CompensationOppose
4Board Proposal to Eliminate Supermajority VotingFor
5Provide Right to Act by Written ConsentOppose